November 9, 2022

November 2022 Election Update

Maine State House

Most of us who are obsessed with electoral politics expected a tight Gubernatorial race and, if not changes in control of the House or Senate, much closer margins between the majority and minority parties in Maine. Governor Janet Mills led in all public polling that took place this election cycle, but given polling inaccuracies in recent years, and the popularity of Governor LePage in his previous election victories, many expected the race to tighten significantly on Election Day. When the final votes were tallied, Governor Mills won re-election by a historically wide margin of 56% compared to LePage’s 42% and Unenrolled candidate Sam Hunkler’s 2%. It is expected that no significant changes will be made to the Governor’s current administrative team. Our Government Affairs Practice Group has close relationships with Governor Mills, her closest staff and her current Commissioners, and we look forward to continuing to work with the Administration over the next four years.

Unexpectedly, the composition of the State Senate did not change in terms of raw numbers. The Senate Democrats once again will hold 22 seats in the Chamber while the Senate Republicans will remain at 13 seats. The only change is that Democrats flipped the Senate seat based in Waterville (with David LaFountain winning) and the Republicans flipped the Senate seat based in Auburn (with Eric Brakey winning)– results that were a surprise to many. Senate Democrats also knew that current Senate President Troy Jackson and Senate Veterans and Legal Affairs Committee Chair, Craig Hickman, were in very tough races and could lose both or either seat. However, at the end of the night both retained their seats by relatively slim margins.

Senate Democrats will choose their leadership team for the 131st Legislature this Thursday, November 10th. We expect that Senate President Jackson, D-Aroostook; Senate Majority Leader Eloise Vitelli, D-Sagadahoc; and Senate Assistant Majority Leader Mattie Daughtry, D-Cumberland, will retain their positions. Senate Republicans will also choose their two legislative leaders on November 10th. Whether current Republican Senate Leader Jeff Timberlake, R-Androscoggin will chose to remain in leadership is unclear. Current Assistant Republican Senate Leader Matt Pouliot, R-Kennebec has announced he will not seek another term in leadership. Names that have been mentioned as potential replacements for open Senate Republican leadership positions include Senators Trey Stewart, R-Aroostook; Lisa Keim, R-Oxford; Brad Farrin, R-Somerset; Rick Bennett, R-Oxford; and Stacey Guerin, R-Penobscot.

Political insiders also expected that the House Republicans had a chance to flip control of the Maine House or to make it a much closer margin between them and the House Democratic Majority. The current make-up of the House is 80 Democrats, 67 Republicans, and 4 left leaning independents. The newly elected House will be 82 Democrats, 67 Republicans and 2 left leaning independents. The House Republicans will choose their leaders next Monday, November 14th, and House Democrats will choose the Speaker and leaders next Thursday, November 17th.

Rep. Rachel Talbot Ross and Rep. Ed Crockett, both D-Portland, have announced interest in the Speaker position. Rep. Maureen Terry, D-Gorham; and Rep. Lori Gramlich, D-Old Orchard Beach, are running to be the House Majority Leader. Rep. Kristen Cloutier, D-Lewiston; and Rep. Rebecca Millett, D-Cape Elizabeth, are running for the Assistant House Majority Leader position.

With both current Republican Leaders term limited, many House Republican members are considering a potential leadership run. Rep. Josh Morris, R-Turner, has expressed his interest in the House Minority Leader position. Other House Republicans who have been mentioned as possible candidates for either open position include Reps. Laurel Libby, R-Auburn; Shelly Rudnicki, R-Fairfield; Dick Campbell, R-Orrington; and Billy Bob Faulkingham, R-Winter Harbor.

Congressional Mid-Terms

In Maine’s 1st Congressional District, Democratic Congresswoman Chellie Pingree handily won her sixth term in office, beating Edwin Thelander. In the 2nd Congressional District, there is a rematch between second term Democratic Congressman Jared Golden and past two-term Congressman Bruce Poliqiun. Golden defeated Poliquin in the ranked choice election in 2018. At this time Golden is leading Poliquin 48.64% - 44.57% with independent Tiffany Bond, who also ran in 2018, getting 6.79%. This means that the race will also go through the ranked choice process. Golden is expected to win re-election, given that Bond’s voters are expected to have listed Golden as their second choice in overwhelming numbers.

Congressional Republicans are expected to win a slim four seat Majority if the current leads in each House seat remain. The U.S Senate could go either way at this time. Who will be in control depends on who ultimately wins in Arizona, Nevada and Georgia. At this writing in Arizona, Democratic Senator Mark Kelly is ahead of Republican Blake Masters 51.4% - 46.4% with 66% of precincts reported. In Nevada Republican Senate Candidate Adam Laxalt is leading incumbent Democratic Senator Catherine Cortez Masto 49.9% - 47.2% with 77% of precincts reported.

If Democrats win both of these races they will retain control of the Senate. If Republicans win both they will gain control of the Senate. However, if each party wins only one of these seats, then control of the Senate will be decided in four weeks when the runoff election in Georgia is decided. With 98% of precincts reported, incumbent Democratic Senator, Raphael Warnock is ahead of Republican candidate Herschel Walker 49.4% - 48.5%, with Libertarian candidate Chase Oliver garnering 2.1%. Unlike Maine, where ranked choice voting is automatic, if no candidate receives over 50% of the vote, Georgia uses the much more expensive and time consuming process of a run-off election between the top two vote getters.

The Preti team will provide another update when leadership decisions are made and keep you informed as committee chair decisions are made, and committee make-up becomes clear. Please don’t hesitate to reach out with any questions, information, or clarification you may need.

Firm Highlights


FY2024 H-1B Registration Fact Sheet for Employers

Registration Process To file H-1B petitions subject to the FY2024 cap for an employee, you must first electronically register and pay a $10 fee for each electronic registration. The electronic registration includes basic information about...


Bodie Colwell will be a Featured Panelist at ABI Annual Spring Meeting

Bodie Colwell will be a featured panelist on "Danger Ahead! Avoiding and Addressing Ethical Landmines in Attorney Engagement and Compensation" at the American Bankruptcy Institute's Annual Spring Meeting. The panel focuses on disputes regarding engagement...


Attorney Jeffrey Thaler Named to 2023 Lawdragon Green 500: Leaders in Energy Law

For the second time, Preti Flaherty attorney Jeffrey Thaler has been recognized by the esteemed legal publication Lawdragon as an elite practitioner in the field of energy law. Jeff is the only Maine-base lawyer...


Enforcers Make It Easy to Report Cartels

This article was originally published in the American Bar Association  Antitrust Newsletter  on February 8, 2023.  Did you know that global competition enforcers have easy-to-find websites to encourage reporting of anticompetitive conduct? Not only...


Maine Lawyers and Judges Once Again Show Overwhelming Support of Campaign for Justice

2022 proved to be another challenging year for Mainers. Skyrocketing inflation, an uncertain economic future, an ongoing housing crisis and more factors continue to push more at-risk individuals into a tight spot. Maine’s civil...


Jeff Talbert to Moderate Panel on PFAS Regulatory Action at ABA Toxic Torts & Environmental Law Conference

Jeff Talbert, Chair of Preti Flaherty's Environmental Law Group, will moderate "Regulatory Action: History & Horizon" at the ABA Toxic Torts & Environmental Law Conference. This panel will discuss the 2016 EPA health advisory, the...


Benchmark Litigation Names Preti Flaherty 2023 “Maine Firm of the Year”

Benchmark Litigation has named Preti Flaherty as 2023 Litigation Firm of the Year in the State of Maine. The Benchmark Awards honor distinguished litigators and law firms in all 50 states and 10 practice...

Press Coverage

Authorities Refuse to Release Records for Maine School Shooter Hoax Calls

On November 15, 2022, multiple law enforcement agencies in Maine received false calls alerting police to active shooter situations at several high schools throughout the state. In the wake of this widespread hoax, the Kennebec...


Maine Workers’ Compensation New Year Update 2023

The new year brings proposed legislation, an update to the Medical Fee Schedule, and two recent decisions from the Appellate Division. Proposed Legislation Workers’ compensation bill LD 53 (HP 28) would amend 39-A M.R.S.A...

Press Coverage

What’s Inside Maine Freight Trains? Public Can Only Hazard a Guess

Due to an exemption from the state's Freedom of Access Act, Maine residents are prevented from reviewing information regarding the transportation through their communities via freight trains of potentially hazardous materials. Rail industry officials...