October 9, 2018 Article

Maine WC Alert: Appellate Division Affirms Finding That Narcotics May Not Be Compensable Based on Long-Term Risks

Maine Workers' Comp Alert

In Martin v. George C. Hall & Sons, Inc., WCB App. Div. No. 18-26 (October 3, 2018), the employee appealed a decision denying compensability of prescription medication, arguing that the administrative law judge (ALJ) erred by considering the risk of narcotic dependence in determining whether the treatment was “reasonable and proper” under § 206. The ALJ was not persuaded by the employee’s testimony that the benefit of narcotic pain medication outweighed the risk of long-term dependence. It found the employee’s treating physician expressed misgivings about his long-term use of narcotics and the § 207 examiner opined that the prescription regimen was inappropriate. Although the employee’s prescribing physician presumably disagreed, the ALJ did not err in resolving the disagreement in favor of non-compensability. “The fact that Mr. Martin’s treatment provided some limited benefit does not compel the conclusion that it is proper, given the competent evidence to the contrary.”

The decision is significant as it demonstrates that, with sufficient supporting evidence, an ALJ may find narcotic prescriptions are not compensable given the risk of dependence. This is particularly important given the recent general health concerns over ongoing narcotic use and the generally high claim costs associated with these medications.

Firm Highlights


WC Alert: Recent Developments from Maine's Workers' Compensation Board

Frank A. Graf, MD, Reappointed to Approved List of § 312 Examiners At the February 11 meeting of the Maine Workers’ Compensation Board, Frank Graf, MD, was reappointed to the list of approved § 312...


Maine WC Alert: WCB Orders Remote Hearings Unless In-Person Deemed Necessary

COVID-19 Concerns Prompt Maine WCB to Order That Hearings Be Conducted Remotely Unless It Is Deemed Necessary to Conduct a Hearing In-Person On March 25, 2020, the Maine WCB issued an order regarding the...


Maine Workers' Comp Alert: Areas of Consideration Due to COVID-19

This alert addresses certain areas of concern with respect to the COVID-19 pandemic and Maine Workers’ Compensation. This alert touches upon new issues to consider, issues of concern for existing claims, and general concerns...


Maine Workers' Comp Alert: WCB Transition to In-Person Hearings Likely to Occur No Sooner Than August 2020; Section 312 IME’s Have Resumed

A conference with Maine Workers' Compensation Board Executive Director John Rohde was held last week to discuss the transition to in-person hearings at the WCB. The WCB Subcommittees also met to discuss recent developments...


Update on COVID-19 and Maine Workers' Compensation

In this uncertain time, Preti Flaherty wants to assure you we are still providing full coverage for your Maine Workers’ Compensation and Longshore legal needs. This update briefly addresses current laws and also touches...


Maine WC Alert: MAE Unit Publishes Guidance on Compliance with Recent Amendments

The Maine Workers’ Compensation Board’s Monitoring, Audit & Enforcement Unit has issued a document to provide guidance on complying with certain recent amendments to the Workers’ Compensation Act in P.L. 2019, c. 344 (LD...


Maine WC Appellate Division Addresses Refusal of Suitable Work and Notice

The Maine Workers' Compensation Appellate Division recently addressed cases dealing with refusal of suitable work and notice. Both decisions rely heavily on the specific facts of each case. In the context of a refusal...


Maine Workers' Comp Alert: WCB Announces New Nature and Cause of Injury Codes and FAQ for COVID-19

New Nature & Cause of Injury Codes The Maine Workers’ Compensation Board (WCB) has updated the Injury Description Tables that are used by the International Association of Industrial Accident Boards and Commissions (IAIABC) to...


Maine WC Alert: Updated Version of Notice of Controversy (WCB-9) Must Be Used Effective February 1, 2020

Following the recent statutory changes to the Workers’ Compensation Act, the Maine Workers’ Compensation Board has updated the language in Box 22 of the Notice of Controversy. This new version should be used as...