Publications
January 1, 1994 Article

David Van Slyke Provides Insight on CERCLA and Allocating the Cost of Municipal Solid Waste Disposal

The Villanova Environmental Law Journal

Municipalities and CERCLA: The Cleanup Cost Allocation Conundrum

Introduction

Out of the chorus of voices disparaging the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act of 1980 ("CERCLA") liability scheme, there has emerged a new loud voice: local governments. Various interest groups, including the American Committees for Cleanup Equity and Local Governments for Superfund Reform, as well as some on Capitol Hill, are now citing the issue of municipal liability under CERCLA as the leading example of the statute's alleged unfairness.

At the center of the debate is whether municipalities should be liable under CERCLA as arrangers for the disposal (generators) or transporters of hazardous substances when municipalities collect, haul, and dispose of municipal solid waste ("MSW"). Municipalities argue that CERCLA's liability scheme was never intended to encompass local governments, especially since municipalities undertake a public function in handling these materials. Furthermore, municipalities argue that saddling them with volume-based liability is similarly unfair since it is industrial waste, not MSW, that is the source of the high pollutant levels prevalent in MSW landfills. The primary opponents of this view, the manufacturing, oil, chemical, and insurance industries, contend that the liability scheme under CERCLA does encompass liability for the generation, transportation, or disposal of MSW, which contains hazardous substances that contribute to the very environmental contamination CERCLA was intended to address. They further argue that the large volume of MSW present in landfills exacerbates the problem.

While municipalities that find themselves owners or operators of a Superfund landfill have raised substantial concerns regarding CERCLA's liability scheme, this Article focuses on CERCLA's effect on municipalities that are generators or transporters of MSW to co-disposal landfills. The discussion below also demonstrates that the caselaw has answered the question of whether municipalities are within the grasp of CERCLA-and the answer is "yes." However, municipalities and other local governments can minimize their exposure through the allocation process. While the courts and the United States Environmental Protection Agency ("EPA") seem to be leaning towards "going easy" on local governments, it is not at all clear that these governments will reap the benefits of this benevolence, given the municipalities' high costs of justifying their minimal share of liability.

Resources

Firm Highlights

News

Preti Flaherty Welcomes Attorneys Michelle Amidzich Fritz and Kat Mail to the Firm

Preti Flaherty is pleased to announce the arrival of attorneys Michelle Amidzich Fritz and Kat Mail. Michelle Amidizich Fritz joins the firm’s Environmental Practice Group in the Boston office. She is a graduate of...

Publication

Post Sackett: What Is the Scope of the Clean Water Act?

The Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) rendered a decision in Sackett et ux. v. EPA addressing what Justice Alito referred to as a “nagging question” of what water bodies are covered under...

Publication

How Much Permitting "Reform" Comes from the New Debt Ceiling Legislation?

Without fanfare or ceremony, on Saturday June 3 rd , President Biden signed the bitterly-negotiated Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2023 (FRA), also known as the Debt Ceiling Limit legislation. While most of the media...

News

David Van Slyke Named to 2024 Lawdragon Green 500: Leaders in Environmental Law

Preti Flaherty’s Managing Partner David Van Slyke has been recognized by Lawdragon as one of the top 500 environmental lawyers in the U.S. It’s the third time he has been named to this prestigious...

News

David Van Slyke Reappointed by Governor Mills to New England Interstate Water Pollution Control Commission

Van Slyke is one of five Commissioners from the state of Maine overseeing NEIWPCC PORTLAND—Preti Flaherty’s Managing Partner, David Van Slyke, has been reappointed by Governor Janet T. Mills to the New England Interstate...