December 17, 2020 Article

Maine Supreme Court Affirms Decision on WCB Rule 2 §5 Termination of Benefits Prior Notice Requirement

Maine Workers' Comp Alert

Notice Is Required Prior to Termination of Benefits for Durational Cap Under Former WCB Rule, Even When Discontinuance Is Sought by Petition

Weekly compensation for partial incapacity benefits under the Workers’ Compensation Act are generally capped at 520 weeks unless certain conditions apply. Per Workers’ Compensation Board Rule 2, §5 an employer can discontinue partial incapacity benefits at the expiration of the 520-week period, but only if the employer has first given the employee 21-days advance notice of the upcoming date of discontinuance and of the employee’s 30-day right to request a hardship extension.

However, the Rule was amended on September 1, 2018, by adding a subsection that shifts the burden to provide notice from the employer to the Board in cases where an order of compensation has been entered. In the meantime, for petitions filed before the amendment took effect, the case of Lorraine Somers v. S.D. Warren Co has significant implications.

In Somers, Administrative Law Judge Elwin found WCB Rule 2, §5 applies only if the employer uses a 21-day Certificate of Discontinuance; it does not apply on an employer’s petition when the decision is issued after the 520-week limit has expired because the employer could not pre-determine the future “date of discontinuance” required by the Rule. Judge Elwin held that applying the rule in these circumstances would be illogical; the date benefits are “due to expire” is unknown and depends on the future issuance of a WCB decision. To avoid an “absurd result,” Judge Elwin interpreted the rule to apply only when the employer seeks discontinuance through a 21-Day Certificate, when the termination date can be identified in advance. The Board entered a decree permitting S.D. Warren and its insurer to discontinue paying Somers partial incapacity benefits when those payments had reached the 520-week statutory limit.

Somers filed a petition to have her benefits reinstated, arguing that S.D. Warren failed to comply with Me. WCB Rule, ch. 2, 5(1) (the former Rule) by not providing her with notice that she could be eligible for an extension of weekly benefits. An ALJ denied the petition.

The WCB Appellate Division vacated that decision.

The Maine Supreme Judicial Court affirmed the judgment of the Appellate Division vacating the judgment denying Somers's petition to have her benefits reinstated, holding that the Appellate Division did not err. The Supreme Judicial Court held that S.D. Warren was required to give Somers notice pursuant to the former Rule before terminating her benefits. The Court affirmed the Appellate Division's decision that the pre-Sept. 1, 2018, version of WCB Rule ch. 2§5(1), requiring specific 21-day advance notice by the employer to the employee prior to termination of benefits paid under §213(1), was consistent with the statute, even when termination of benefits after 520 weeks was accomplished via decree on a contested petition for review.

Firm Highlights


How to Avoid Misclassifying Your Employees Under the Maine Workers’ Compensation Act

What criteria are necessary to classify someone as an independent contractor and how can employers avoid misclassification and the repercussions that come with it? In this article, Preti Flaherty attorney and Mainebiz guest columnist John...


Maine Workers' Comp Alert: WCB Revises Fee Schedule

The Maine Workers' Compensation Board has completed the annual update of its Medical Fee Schedule. Appendix II (professional fees) and Appendix IV (outpatient facility fees) have been updated in accordance with Title 39-A M.R.S.A...


46 Preti Flaherty Attorneys Selected by Peers for Inclusion in Best Lawyers in America 2022, Including 3 “Lawyers of the Year”

Forty-six Preti Flaherty attorneys have been named to Best Lawyers in America 2022, including four “Ones to Watch” and three “Lawyer of the Year” recipients. Inclusion in Best Lawyers in America is considered a...


Maine Workers' Comp Alert: Maine Supreme Court Issues Decision Regarding Statute of Limitations in Coordination of Benefits

Maine Supreme Court Issues Decision in Charest v. Hydraulic Hose Dealing with Unique Statute of Limitations Issue in the Context of the Coordination of Benefits On March 30, 2021, the Law Court issued a...


Maine Workers' Comp Alert: WCB December Updates - Covid-19 Claim Statistics and Appeal Accepted by Law Court

The Maine Workers’ Compensation Board met for its regular business meeting on December 8. Among the items discussed were COVID-19 claim statistics and an appeal accepted by the Law Court dealing with a fascinating...


Maine Workers' Comp Alert: WCB Meeting Notes for June 2021

The following are highlights from the Maine Workers’ Compensation Board’s meeting of June 8, 2021. Attorney Kate Gatti Rooks Appointed for Partial Term as Administrative Law Judge in Portland Attorney Kate Gatti Rooks was...


Legal Lunches: Workin' for the Weekend

Laura Rideout and John Cronan will participate in a panel discussion called "Workin' for the Weekend: Team Safety Including Wage & Hour, OSHA and Workers' Comp in a Post-COVID World" as a part of...


Maine Workers' Comp Alert: Appellate Division Affirms Decision Involving Gradual Injury That First Manifested at Home, Not at Work

In Thomas v. United Ambulance , United Ambulance appealed a Decision (Goodnough, ALJ) granting Thomas’s Petition for Award and granting in part his Petition for Payment. United Ambulance argued that the ALJ erred in...


Maine Workers' Comp Alert: WCB Updates Guidance on COVID-19 Reporting and Related Requirements

The Maine Workers’ Compensation Board has updated its COVID-19 FAQ with current guidance and reporting requirements. Although the information offered is not legal advice and is not judicially enforceable, it is helpful direction in...


Maine Workers' Comp Alert: Updates from the WCB February Monthly Business Meeting

The WCB met remotely on February 9, 2021, for its monthly business meeting. Following are some developments with respect to an appeal accepted by the Maine Supreme Court and claims related to Covid-19. COVID-Coded...