Publications
September 18, 2017 Article

Environmental Alert: Bona Fide Prospective Purchaser Escapes CERCLA Liability

Environmental Alert

The owners of a shipyard sued a prior owner and the current owner of an adjacent former steel mill property in Baltimore, Maryland for recovery of cleanup costs under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (“CERCLA” or “Superfund”).   At issue was the cost of cleanup being conducted by the plaintiffs as a result of passive migration of contaminants via groundwater from the former steel mill property to the shipyard property.

The prior owner of the steel mill property, Sparrow Point LLC, had purchased it out of bankruptcy in 2012 pursuant to an agreement approved by the U.S. Bankruptcy Court.  In 2014 Sparrow Point sold the property to defendant Tradepoint Atlantic LLC.  Upon purchasing the property, Tradepoint entered into an administrative consent order with the Maryland Department of the Environment and a settlement agreement with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency to conduct various cleanup activities.

Tradepoint asserted that it was not liable under CERCLA due to its status as a Bona Fide Prospective Purchaser (“BFPP”).  BFPP status exempts parties that would otherwise be liable as an owner or operator under CERCLA. To qualify for the BFPP exemption, the current owner/operator must have acquired the facility after January 1, 2002 and must establish compliance with eight criteria. 

Plaintiffs argued that Tradepoint failed to establish two of the BFPP elements:  (a) that the disposal of hazardous substances must have occurred before acquisition of the facility, and (b) that there be no “affiliation” between the BFPP and the parties responsible for the contamination.  Plaintiffs argued that the passive migration of benzene constituted a new act of disposal and that both Sparrow Point and Tradepoint were “affiliated through a web of corporate relationships” with the previous owners of the steel mill that were designed to “scrub the environmental liabilities” from the former steel mill property.

The Maryland federal district court rejected these arguments.  The court noted it was undisputed that the contamination at issue originated prior to the defendants’ purchase of the steel mill property and was “merely the passive flow of benzene through groundwater” that neither defendant had caused or exacerbated (and was, in fact, exacerbated by plaintiffs’ own pumping activities).   Further, pointing to Tradepoint’s agreements with state and federal environmental regulators, the court found that Tradepoint had not structured its acquisition of the former steel mill property to avoid liability.  The court concluded that as there was no post-acquisition “disposal” of hazardous substances or any “affiliation” between Tradepoint and any responsible party for the purpose of avoiding liability.

Successfully running the gauntlet of requirements to obtain BFPP status is not easy.  Very few court decisions provide guideposts for obtaining and maintaining BFPP liability exemptions.  While nothing can prevent a BFPP from being sued, this decision gives some comfort to prospective purchasers that careful efforts to attain BFPP status are worthwhile, and can and will be honored by the courts.

Firm Highlights

Event

Sigmund Schutz to moderate panel at 36th Annual Media and the Law Seminar: Under Attack! Existential Threats to Journalism and Free Speech

From unlawful searches and seizures of newsrooms and highly contentious litigation to physical harassment and calls for violence online, journalists and news organizations are under attack like never before. At the 36 th Annual...

Event

Hire Education: Best Practices for Onboarding New Employees

As an HR professional, hiring the right talent, addressing employee needs, and managing terminations are just a few of the most challenging problems that arise. During this year's three-part Employment Breakfast Webinar Series, we'll...

News

Benchmark Litigation Names Preti Flaherty 2024 “Maine Firm of the Year"

Benchmark Litigation has named Preti Flaherty as 2024 Litigation Firm of the Year in the State of Maine. Through extensive peer- and- client reviewed research, as well as analysis of casework; the Benchmark Awards...

News

Preti Attorneys File Suit Against Al-Generated Robocalls in the 2024 NH Presidential Primary

Representing the League of Women Voters of New Hampshire, the League of Women Voters of the United States, and individual voters, Preti Flaherty, with co-counsel, filed a federal lawsuit against Steve Kramer, Lingo Telecom...

News

Attorney Jeffrey Thaler Named to 2024 Lawdragon Green 500: Leaders in Energy Law

Preti Flaherty’s attorney Jeffrey Thaler has been recognized by  Lawdragon  as one of the top 500 Leaders in Energy Law. This is Jeff’s third time named to this prestigious list since the first publication...

Publication

Important Updates to American Arbitration Association Construction Industry Rules and Mediation Procedures

The American Arbitration Association (AAA) updated its Construction Industry Rules and Mediation procedures (AAA Rules), effective March 1, 2024, marking the first update since 2015. The updates are important because the AAA Rules are...

Publication

Helping Employers Navigate the New Independent Contractor Rule and Compliance Challenges

On March 11 th , the United States Department of Labor’s (DOL) new Independent Contractor Rule goes into effect.  As your organization readies itself for compliance, it’s imperative to scrutinize your independent contractor classifications...

Publication

Failure to Follow Your Contract's Notice Requirements Can be Costly

In Kinetic Systems, Inc. v. IPS-Integrated Projects Services, LLC et. al., No.: 20-cv-1125 (D.N.H. February 6, 2024), the U.S. District Court for the District of New Hampshire granted summary judgment for a general contractor...

Publication

USCIS Announces H-1B Registration Period for FY2025: New “Beneficiary Centric” Registration Process and Increased Fees

USCIS has recently announced a series of changes that will impact the FY2025 H-1B registration system and cap filing season. H-1B Registration Period and Organizational Accounts As in prior years, under this process, prospective petitioners...

Event

Legal Foundations Lunch and Learn Series: Understanding Indemnity Clauses

Our Legal Foundations Lunch and Learn Series features monthly 30-minute webinars that provide in-depth insights into recent updates, industry trends, and key issues impacting the construction industry. Preti Flaherty attorneys Kenneth Rubinstein and Nicholas...