Publications
November 17, 2017 Article

Maine WC Appellate Division Rejects Petitions for Individual Permanent Impairment Raitings in the Face of a Prior Combined Rating

Maine Workers' Comp Alert

In Puiia v. NewPage Corp., an employee sustained respiratory injuries in 2001 and 2004, and a back/neck injury in 2005. In 2009, NewPage filed petitions to determine Permanent Impairment for all injuries. In a 2010 consent decree, the Board found the Permanent Impairment rating for the combined effects of all injuries was 19%. There was no determination of permanency for any individual injury.

Later, NewPage filed petitions to determine Permanent Impairment due to the 2001 and 2004 respiratory injuries. NewPage requested Permanent Impairment ratings for each respiratory injury because Permanent Impairment ratings had not been determined in the previous litigation. The administrative law judge (ALJ) denied the petitions, finding that the 2010 consent decree establishing a combined Permanent Impairment rating for the three injuries precluded separate determinations for the individual injuries under the doctrine of res judicata.

The Appellate Division affirmed. It held that the Law Court's recent decision in Bailey v. City of Lewiston, barred NewPage's petitions in this case. In Bailey, the Law Court held that a permanent impairment finding in a Decree cannot be modified in subsequent litigation. However, even if Bailey did not apply, res judicata barred NewPage's petitions. This is because, although the permanency rating for each injury was not decided in the 2010 decree, medical evidence at the time included impairment ratings for the individual injuries. In other words, individual ratings could have been established back in 2010, but they were not.

Firm Highlights

Publication

Maine WC Alert: Appellate Division Upholds Ruling on Reinstatement Provisions and Termination of Benefits

Maine WC Appellate Division Holds That Ongoing Noncompliance with Reinstatement Provisions in Section 218 Precludes Termination of Benefits for Expiration of Durational Cap Under 213 Section 218 of the Maine Workers’ Compensation Act provides...

Publication

Maine WC Alert: New Legislation Brings Procedural Changes, Benefit Modifications

LD 756 (“ An Act To Improve the Maine Workers’ Compensation Act of 1992 ”), was signed into law by Governor Mills on June 17, 2019. LD 756 has an effective date of September...

Publication

Maine WC Alert: MAE Unit Publishes Guidance on Compliance with Recent Amendments

The Maine Workers’ Compensation Board’s Monitoring, Audit & Enforcement Unit has issued a document to provide guidance on complying with certain recent amendments to the Workers’ Compensation Act in P.L. 2019, c. 344 (LD...

Publication

Maine WC Alert: Latest Appellate Division Rulings on Health Insurance Payments, Social Security Benefits

The Maine Workers' Comp Appellate Division recently issued rulings in the cases of Rich v. Maine Turnpike Authority and Butler v. City of Portland. Health Insurance Payments Made by Self-Insured Employer for Health Insurance...

Publication

Maine WC Alert: Updated Version of Notice of Controversy (WCB-9) Must Be Used Effective February 1, 2020

Following the recent statutory changes to the Workers’ Compensation Act, the Maine Workers’ Compensation Board has updated the language in Box 22 of the Notice of Controversy. This new version should be used as...

Publication

Maine WC Alert: Appellate Division Clarifies Section 327 Death Presumption

Maine Workers' Compensation Appellate Division Clarifies Burdens of Production and Proof Regarding Notice in the Context of the Section 327 Death Presumption In Estate of Deyone v. ITG Brands, LLC (WCB App. Div. 19-7...

Publication

Maine WC Alert: Appellate Division Reiterates Requirement to Trigger Retirement Presumption

Maine Workers' Comp Appellate Division Reiterates That Working in Customary Job Until Retirement Constitutes “Termination of Active Employment” Sufficient to Trigger the Retirement Presumption In Capitan v. NewPage Paper (WCB 19-10 [App. Div. April...

Publication

Maine WC Appellate Division Addresses Refusal of Suitable Work and Notice

The Maine Workers' Compensation Appellate Division recently addressed cases dealing with refusal of suitable work and notice. Both decisions rely heavily on the specific facts of each case. In the context of a refusal...

Publication

Maine WC Alert: Appellate Division Rules No Consequences Under 218 for Deferment of Receipt of Old-Age Social Security Benefits

In Pratt v. S.D. Warren (No. 19-3 [WCB App. Div. April 30, 2019]), S.D. Warren appealed a decision denying its Petition for Approval of Discontinuance of Incapacity Benefits. An employer may reduce incapacity benefits...

Publication

Maine WC Alert: Appellate Division Addresses the Issue of Timely Notice in Two Recent Decisions

For claims for which the date of injury is on or after January 1, 2013, unless otherwise provided by the Maine Workers' Compensation Act, proceedings may not be maintained unless notice of an injury...