November 13, 2017 Article

Maine WC Appellate Division Confirms Work Search Evidence Alone May Be Sufficient to Prevail on Petition for Review

Maine Workers' Comp Alert

In Pelletier v. Gerald Pelletier, Inc., Me. WCB App. Div. No. 17-34 (October 30, 2017), the Employee appealed from a decision denying his Petition for Review through which he sought an increase in partial incapacity benefits. The Employee argued that the administrative law judge (ALJ) erred when he held that work search evidence alone cannot, as a matter of law, prove a change of economic circumstances necessary to overcome the res judicata effect of a prior decision.

An employee whose level of incapacity benefits has been established by decree may overcome the res judicata effect of that prior decision with evidence that demonstrates a change of economic circumstances. Here, the ALJ did not evaluate the strength of the Employee’s work search evidence based on the multifactorial test in Monaghan v. Jordan’s Meats, but, instead, interpreted McIntyre v. Great Northern Paper, Inc., 2000 ME 6, to hold that work search evidence, without more, is insufficient, as a matter of law, to prove a change of economic circumstances.

The Appellate Division does not read McIntyre as foreclosing review of the level of partial incapacity when work search evidence is the only proof of changed economic circumstances. As explained by the Appellate Division, the Law Court in McIntyre held that an employee’s work search, coupled with vocational training and obtaining employment, was sufficient to demonstrate an economic change in circumstances. The Law Court did not hold that work search evidence alone was insufficient and the Appellate Division declined to create such a rule. The Appellate Division also noted that prohibiting an injured employee receiving partial incapacity benefits from seeking an increase in benefits after engaging in an extensive work search would thwart “the purpose of the Act to encourage employees to look for post-injury employment.”

Further, as explained by the Appellate Division, in determining whether changed circumstances exist, McIntyre emphasized the need to identify the basis on which the previous award was made. In this case, the Board based its earlier award of partial incapacity benefits mainly on its rejection of the employee’s argument that he was medically totally incapacitated. The Appellate Division found that, under these facts, “it would be particularly inappropriate to bar him from attempting to establish a higher level of partial incapacity based on a work search exploring the availability of work within his restrictions because, before the prior decree, it was not yet clear that "the employee had any work capacity and would, therefore, be expected to seek work.”

The decision was vacated and remanded for additional findings. The ALJ was instructed to assess whether the Employee’s work search evidence “constitutes a significant change in circumstances relating to the extent of his incapacity.”

Firm Highlights


Maine Workers' Comp Alert: Update on Appellate Division Findings on Notice of Injury Requirements

Maine WC Appellate Division Affirms Decision Finding Untimely Notice of Injury; Reiterates Requirements for Timely Notice As background, the notice period is 90 days for dates of injury between January 1, 1993, and January...


Maine WC Alert: WCB Orders Remote Hearings Unless In-Person Deemed Necessary

COVID-19 Concerns Prompt Maine WCB to Order That Hearings Be Conducted Remotely Unless It Is Deemed Necessary to Conduct a Hearing In-Person On March 25, 2020, the Maine WCB issued an order regarding the...


Maine Workers' Comp Alert: WCB Announces Updates to Several Forms

The Maine Workers’ Compensation Board has revised several forms, which are now available here . The WCB-4 (Discontinuance/Modification) has been divided into two new forms, WCB-4D (Discontinuance) and WCB-4M (Modification). The Discontinuance, Modification, and...


Maine Workers' Comp Alert: WCB Transition to In-Person Hearings Likely to Occur No Sooner Than August 2020; Section 312 IME’s Have Resumed

A conference with Maine Workers' Compensation Board Executive Director John Rohde was held last week to discuss the transition to in-person hearings at the WCB. The WCB Subcommittees also met to discuss recent developments...


Maine Workers' Comp Alert: Areas of Consideration Due to COVID-19

This alert addresses certain areas of concern with respect to the COVID-19 pandemic and Maine Workers’ Compensation. This alert touches upon new issues to consider, issues of concern for existing claims, and general concerns...


Maine Workers' Comp Alert: WCB Announces New Nature and Cause of Injury Codes and FAQ for COVID-19

New Nature & Cause of Injury Codes The Maine Workers’ Compensation Board (WCB) has updated the Injury Description Tables that are used by the International Association of Industrial Accident Boards and Commissions (IAIABC) to...


WC Alert: Recent Developments from Maine's Workers' Compensation Board

Frank A. Graf, MD, Reappointed to Approved List of § 312 Examiners At the February 11 meeting of the Maine Workers’ Compensation Board, Frank Graf, MD, was reappointed to the list of approved § 312...


Update on COVID-19 and Maine Workers' Compensation

In this uncertain time, Preti Flaherty wants to assure you we are still providing full coverage for your Maine Workers’ Compensation and Longshore legal needs. This update briefly addresses current laws and also touches...


Attorney Evan Hansen Selected by Peers as “Lawyer of the Year” in Best Lawyers in America 2021

Preti Flaherty attorney Evan Hansen has been recognized in Best Lawyers in America 2021 as the “Lawyer of the Year” for the Portland region in the field of Workers' Compensation Law - Employers. Inclusion in...


48 Preti Flaherty Attorneys Selected by Peers for Inclusion in Best Lawyers in America 2021, Including 4 “Lawyers of the Year”

Forty-eight Preti Flaherty attorneys have been named to Best Lawyers in America 2021, including four recognized on the inaugural “Ones to Watch” list for attorneys earlier in their careers and four “Lawyer of the...