Environmental

Stormwater

Publications
January 3, 2017 Article

Environmental Alert: U.S. EPA Chooses Flexible Approach to Stormwater General Permit for Small Communities

Environmental Alert

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is issuing a final rule revising the regulations governing how small municipal separate storm sewer systems (MS4s) obtain coverage under National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) general permits issued by NPDES permitting authorities (including EPA regional offices) and the way required permit conditions are established under the Clean Water Act (CWA). The final rule becomes effective on January 9, 2017.

The rule results from a decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit in Environmental Defense Center, et al. v. EPA, at 344 F.3d 832 (9th Cir. 2003) (“EDC decision”), which found that EPA regulations for obtaining coverage under a small MS4 general permit did not provide for adequate public notice, the opportunity to request a hearing, or permitting authority review to determine whether the best management practices (BMPs) selected by each MS4 in its stormwater management program (SWMP) meets the CWA requirements including the requirement to “reduce pollutants to the maximum extent practicable.”

Under the rule, EPA is taking a “Permitting Authority Choice Approach” that enables the permitting authority to choose between a “traditional” general permit approach under which all steps to achieve Clean Water Act compliance are spelled out in detail up front and a two-step “procedural” approach.  Under the procedural approach an MS4 operator would first submit its Notice of Intent (NOI) requesting coverage under a “base” general permit that the permitting authority would review and assess for compliance.  The public then would be given an opportunity to comment and request a hearing on the merits of the MS4’s proposed BMPs and measurable goals for complying with CWA requirements.  The MS4 would then be required to comply with the requirements of the base general permit as well as any additional requirements established as a result of the public comment process.  The permitting authority could also choose to implement a combination of the traditional and procedural approaches in issuing and authorizing coverage under a general permit. 

The hybrid approach taken by EPA is generally viewed favorably by municipalities because of the flexibility it provides for both permitting authorities and MS4s. 

EPA does not expect permitting authorities to reopen MS4 general permits currently in effect to comply with the new rule.  Similarly, in those few states where permits are to expire shortly and where the state has already proposed a permit, is in the final stages of permit issuance (i.e., where the public comment period has closed), or has issued a permit prior to the effective date of the rule, EPA does not expect the permit issuance process to be reopened.  However, any new MS4 general permits are to comply with the rule. 

In Region 1, EPA is the MS4 permitting authority for Massachusetts and New Hampshire but has delegated MS4 permitting authority to Connecticut, Maine, Rhode Island, and Vermont.  Under EPA’s 2016 Massachusetts MS4 general permit (effective July 1, 2017), and the draft 2013 New Hampshire MS4 general permit (which has been the subject of extended public comment periods and is not yet finalized), submission of a detailed NOI is required with a minimum 30-day public comment period thereafter, following which EPA may impose additional requirements based on its own review as well as review of comments received.  It appears that Region 1 is taking the traditional approach in these states.  

Connecticut recently reissued its MS4 general permit, which will become effective on July 1, 2017.  The Maine MS4 general permit is not due to expire until 2018.  The Rhode Island MS4 general permit expired in 2008 and has been administratively continued since; to date no proposed draft permit has been issued.  The Vermont permit was issued in 2012 and is scheduled to expire in December 2017.  No changes are anticipated in these state permits until they are reissued.   

The final rule also requires that that permit terms and conditions be “clear, specific, and measurable.”  While some commenters on the rule were in favor of greater certainty, others expressed concerned about potential restrictions on flexibility in meeting permit requirements.  In association with the promulgation of the final rule, EPA is updating its Compendium of MS4 Permitting Approaches to assist permitting authorities in establishing appropriate permit language.  The Compendium provides examples of permitting language that EPA regards as acceptable, as well as language that, in EPA’s view, does not qualify as clear, specific and measurable.

As delegated states start the process of reissuing their existing MS4 general permits, it can be anticipated that a much more involved effort will be required of permitting authorities when they draft new permits, including having to choose among the traditional, two-step procedural, and hybrid approaches for authorizing MS4 permit coverage.

Firm Highlights

Event

Legal Foundations Lunch and Learn Series: Understanding Indemnity Clauses

Our Legal Foundations Lunch and Learn Series features monthly 30-minute webinars that provide in-depth insights into recent updates, industry trends, and key issues impacting the construction industry. Preti Flaherty attorneys Kenneth Rubinstein and Nicholas...

Publication

Important Updates to American Arbitration Association Construction Industry Rules and Mediation Procedures

The American Arbitration Association (AAA) updated its Construction Industry Rules and Mediation procedures (AAA Rules), effective March 1, 2024, marking the first update since 2015. The updates are important because the AAA Rules are...

News

Benchmark Litigation Names Preti Flaherty 2024 “Maine Firm of the Year"

Benchmark Litigation has named Preti Flaherty as 2024 Litigation Firm of the Year in the State of Maine. Through extensive peer- and- client reviewed research, as well as analysis of casework; the Benchmark Awards...

Publication

Helping Employers Navigate the New Independent Contractor Rule and Compliance Challenges

On March 11 th , the United States Department of Labor’s (DOL) new Independent Contractor Rule goes into effect.  As your organization readies itself for compliance, it’s imperative to scrutinize your independent contractor classifications...

News

Attorney Jeffrey Thaler Named to 2024 Lawdragon Green 500: Leaders in Energy Law

Preti Flaherty’s attorney Jeffrey Thaler has been recognized by  Lawdragon  as one of the top 500 Leaders in Energy Law. This is Jeff’s third time named to this prestigious list since the first publication...

Event

Sigmund Schutz to moderate panel at 36th Annual Media and the Law Seminar: Under Attack! Existential Threats to Journalism and Free Speech

From unlawful searches and seizures of newsrooms and highly contentious litigation to physical harassment and calls for violence online, journalists and news organizations are under attack like never before. At the 36 th Annual...

Publication

USCIS Announces H-1B Registration Period for FY2025: New “Beneficiary Centric” Registration Process and Increased Fees

USCIS has recently announced a series of changes that will impact the FY2025 H-1B registration system and cap filing season. H-1B Registration Period and Organizational Accounts As in prior years, under this process, prospective petitioners...

News

Preti Attorneys File Suit Against Al-Generated Robocalls in the 2024 NH Presidential Primary

Representing the League of Women Voters of New Hampshire, the League of Women Voters of the United States, and individual voters, Preti Flaherty, with co-counsel, filed a federal lawsuit against Steve Kramer, Lingo Telecom...

Event

Hire Education: Best Practices for Onboarding New Employees

As an HR professional, hiring the right talent, addressing employee needs, and managing terminations are just a few of the most challenging problems that arise. During this year's three-part Employment Breakfast Webinar Series, we'll...

Publication

Failure to Follow Your Contract's Notice Requirements Can be Costly

In Kinetic Systems, Inc. v. IPS-Integrated Projects Services, LLC et. al., No.: 20-cv-1125 (D.N.H. February 6, 2024), the U.S. District Court for the District of New Hampshire granted summary judgment for a general contractor...