Under Federal ERISA law, employers are required to allow certain employees
and their dependents who would otherwise lose coverage under a group health plan
as a result of certain specified events to elect to continue that coverage for
specified periods at their own expense. This bundle of rights is commonly known
as COBRA coverage.
COBRA coverage can be triggered by such "qualifying
events" as death, termination (for reasons other than gross misconduct) or
reduction of hours, divorce or legal separation, Medicare entitlement, change of
status of a dependent child or employer bankruptcy; termination may include
retirement, resignation or layoff. The plan administrator is responsible for
notifying "qualified beneficiaries" of their COBRA rights. Qualified
beneficiaries include an employee's spouse and dependents as well as the
employee in certain circumstances, such as when termination or reduction of
hours causes loss of coverage. Generally, the employer is the plan administrator
unless the plan is offered under an arrangement involving multiple employers or
unless the responsibilities of the plan administrator have been contracted out
to a third party.
The duty to notify the employee of his or her COBRA rights
arises by statute and is independent of a beneficiary's actual knowledge of
those rights. Furthermore, a plan is not relieved of its obligation to provide
COBRA benefits because the plan's underlying insurance policy does not include
COBRA coverage. Coverage must be provided even if the plan has to self-insure
it. Even if COBRA coverage is included in the insurance policy, an employer
should take pains to notify its insurer promptly of an employee's change of
status. Because a plan's obligation to provide COBRA coverage is independent of
the actions of an insurer, an employer thinking about changing carriers should
also obtain advance confirmation from a prospective new insurer as to how
existing COBRA beneficiaries will be treated.
COBRA contains no specific
requirements as to the manner in which the notice of the right to continue
coverage must be given. In some instances, a good-faith attempt to comply with a
reasonable interpretation of the statute is sufficient. Generally, the notice
must contain sufficient detail as to the costs and benefits of coverage to allow
the beneficiary to make an informed decision about whether to elect coverage.
Although it is by far the better practice, written notice is not required. Thus,
an employer who is also the plan administrator may give a terminated employee
oral notice of his or her COBRA rights, provided it can be shown that the
employee was adequately advised of those rights. The plan administrator bears
the burden of proving that adequate notice was given.
Failure to give proper notice of COBRA rights can be expensive. A court
has the discretion to hold a plan administrator that fails to provide the
required notice personally liable for an amount that can be as much as $110 per
day. A court may also rule that an employer's failure to give the required COBRA
notice can entitle a qualified beneficiary to coverage of any medical expenses
that the beneficiary incurred during the period for which COBRA coverage might
otherwise have been enforced.
Even if COBRA coverage is unnecessarily or
mistakenly activated, the plan's acceptance of a COBRA election and premium
payments may create a contract between the plan and the beneficiary. The plan
may not only have to pay the benefits during the period for which it accepted
the premiums, but it may also be responsible for providing continuation coverage
during the maximum period allowed under COBRA. Moreover, if there were no
requirement to offer COBRA coverage, this additional benefit may not be covered
by the employer's group health insurance.